Your Cart is Empty
Best Honey Extractor Buyer’s Guide : Manual vs Electric Options Compared
The sweet reward of beekeeping is, without a doubt, the honey harvest! To efficiently get that golden goodness from your honeycomb frames, you'll need essential tools: honey extractors. Choosing the perfect honey extractor can feel like a big decision on your beekeeping journey, directly impacting your honey yield and making the whole extraction process a breeze (or a backache!). This detailed guide will help you sort through the various types of honey extractors, comparing manual vs. electric options, with a close look at the diverse range from Mann Lake, plus insights into other popular brands.
Key Takeaways
- Manual extractors are cost-effective and portable, ideal for small-scale beekeepers. Electric models, though a larger investment, offer significant time and physical effort savings for larger operations thanks to their electric motor.
- Radial extractors are highly efficient, spinning honey from both sides of the frame at once. Tangential extractors are often more affordable and can handle deep frames, but require flipping frames.
- Mann Lake offers a remarkably diverse and high-quality range of extractors, from compact manual extractors perfect for a backyard beekeeper to powerful electric models designed for commercial operations. Their variety ensures there's a perfect honey extractor for every stage of your beekeeping journey.
- Match the extractor's honey yield capacity to your number of hives. A 2-4 frame is great for beginners, while larger beekeeping operations will benefit immensely from 18+ frame or even 40-80 frame electric models.
- When buying, look for durable stainless steel construction, the type of hand crank (top or side), the frame compatibility (shallow, medium, deep frames), and features like variable speed control or integrated augers for larger units.
Table of Contents
- Understanding Honey Extractor Basics: Tangential vs. Radial
- Manual vs. Electric Honey Extractors: Which Is Best for You?
- Mann Lake Honey Extractors: Your Go-To for Every Beekeeping Need
- Mann Lake Manual Extractors: Reliable and Ready
- Mann Lake Electric and Hybrid Extractors: Power and Precision
- How Mann Lake Stacks Up Against Other Top Brands
- Choosing Your Best Honey Extractor
- Frequently Asked Questions
Understanding Honey Extractor Basics: Tangential vs. Radial
Before we dive into specific models, let's quickly grasp the two main ways honey extractors work: tangential and radial. Both use centrifugal force to spin honey out of the frames, but they do it a little differently.
Tangential Extractors
Radial Extractors
Imagine your frames standing on their side, facing the drum wall. When you spin them, the centrifugal force pulls honey from just one side of the frame. This means you'll have to stop, flip the frame, and spin it again to get the honey from the second side. While they're often more affordable, especially for deep frames, they do require more physical effort and time because of all that flipping. Many smaller manual extractors are tangential.
Picture your frames like the spokes of a wheel, with the top bars pointing outwards. As the drum spins, the magic of centrifugal force extracts honey from both sides of the frame simultaneously! This really speeds up the honey extraction process and saves your back, making radial extractors a popular choice for beekeepers who value efficiency, especially with lots of shallow frames or medium frames.
Manual vs. Electric Honey Extractors: Which Is Best for You?
Deciding between manual models and electric options really comes down to a few things: the size of your beekeeping operations, your budget, and how much convenience you're looking for.
Manual Honey Extractors
Manual extractors are typically controlled by a hand crank. They're often a fantastic option for small-scale beekeepers, hobbyist beekeepers, or a new beekeeper with just a small number of hives (think 1-5).
Pros
- Affordability: Generally, manual honey extractor units come at a lower price point, making them an accessible way to start extracting honey.
- Portability: Many manual units are lighter and more compact, which means they're easier to move around and store.
- No Power Required: They work independently of an electric motor, making them ideal for off-grid situations or if your power isn't always reliable.
- Control: You have direct control over the spinning speed, which can be great for delicate comb.
Cons
- Physical Effort: Extracting honey from multiple frames takes a fair bit of physical effort, especially during a large honey harvest.
- Time-Consuming: The process is slower than with electric models, particularly with tangential extractors where you need to flip frames.
- Limited Capacity: Manual extractors usually hold fewer frames, meaning more batches for larger harvests.
Electric Honey Extractors
Electric extractors, powered by an electric motor, automate the spinning. They're an excellent choice for larger operations, a seasoned beekeeper, and anyone who wants speed and efficiency.
Pros
- Time-Saving & Efficiency: The electric motor automates the spin, drastically cutting down on the time and physical effort needed for the extraction of honey. This is especially true for radial extractors.
- Higher Capacity: Electric models often boast a larger capacity, letting you extract more frames per batch.
- Reduced Physical Strain: Say goodbye to strenuous hand crank action! Electric models do the work, making your honey harvest much less demanding.
- Consistent Spin: An electric motor provides a consistent, controlled spin, which helps ensure uniform honey removal. Many even offer adjustable speed settings.
Cons
- Higher Cost: Electric options generally come with a higher price tag than their manual counterparts.
- Power Dependency: They need access to an electrical outlet, which might be a limitation for some beekeepers.
- Weight & Size: They're usually heavier and bigger, meaning you'll need more dedicated storage space.
Mann Lake Honey Extractors: Your Go-To for Every Beekeeping Need
Mann Lake is a well-respected name in the beekeeping community, a true leader known for producing a huge variety of quality honey extractor options. From the perfect starter extractor to robust machines for large-scale operations, Mann Lake genuinely offers something for every beekeeper. Let's explore why their range stands out.
Mann Lake Manual Extractors: Reliable and Ready
HH940 3 Frame Steel Side Hand Crank
This compact stainless steel extractor is absolutely great for beginner beekeepers.
It holds 3 frames (shallow, medium, or deep) and features a handy side hand crank, a clear plastic top, and a sturdy metal stand for easy honey draining. It's a reliable, user-friendly choice for a backyard beekeeper.
HH130 Plastic Two-Frame Honey Extractor
If you're looking for ultimate portability and a super budget-friendly option for just a couple of hives, this lightweight, UV-stable food-grade plastic extractor is your go-to. It's small, mighty, and easy to clean.
HH160 and HH162 6/3 Frame Steel Hand Crank
These similar 26-gauge stainless steel models are incredibly versatile. They can handle 3 deep or medium frames tangentially, or 6 shallow frames radially.
Perfect if you have different frame types and prefer a straightforward manual crank. Note: the stand is sold separately for the 6/3, but it's a worthwhile addition.
HH190 6/3 Frame Side Hand Crank Honey Extractor
Similar to the above in capacity, this stainless steel extractor offers a side crank with brake legs for added stability – a really nice touch that makes the job smoother!
HH170 18/9 Frame Hand Crank Radial Extractor
For hobbyist beekeepers with a larger number of hives who still prefer a manual honey extractor, this radial extractor is a serious contender.
It spins 18 shallow/medium or 9 deep frames, offering much better efficiency than a tangential manual unit. It even includes a stand, making it ready to go right out of the box!
Mann Lake Electric and Hybrid Extractors: Power and Precision
HH163 Stainless Steel 8/4 Frame Basket Honey Extractor
This is a fantastic hybrid option! Made from durable 26-gauge stainless steel, it offers the ultimate flexibility, allowing for manual hand crank OR electric use.
It holds 4 deep frames, or 8 medium/shallow frames. It's a smart choice for beekeepers who might want to start manual and upgrade to an electric motor later, growing with your beekeeping operations.
HH200 6/3 Frame Motorized Honey Extractor
Ready to go electric? This motorized extractor handles 3 deep/medium or 6 shallow frames with a smooth, gear-driven 110V motor and variable speed control.
It's an excellent choice for a growing backyard beekeeper looking for significantly less physical effort.
HH215 and HH280 Motorized Radial 18/9 Frame
These electric models are a step up for more serious hobbyists or small-scale commercial beekeepers.
They efficiently handle 18 shallow/medium or 9 deep frames radially, making the extraction process much faster and easier, consistently delivering great results.
HH813 24-Frame Radial Honey Extractor with Auger
Now we're getting into serious territory! This electric extractor boasts a 24-frame radial design, a robust 1/2 HP drive motor, a 3/4 HP pump/auger motor, and even a built-in auger for seamlessly transferring honey.
It's an incredibly efficient option for larger operations that demand automated processes.
HH913/HH926 24- or 48-Frame Radial Extractor (without auger)
These big boys are designed for high-volume extraction.
The HH913 handles 24 frames, and the HH926 tackles a massive 48 frames, making them ideal for commercial operations focused on maximizing honey yield with top-tier efficiency.
HH826 48-Frame Radial Extractor with Integrated Pump/Auger
This powerhouse is built for continuous, high-volume work.
It extracts 48 frames simultaneously, featuring a 1 HP DC drive motor, 1 HP DC pump/auger motor, and an integrated system for lateral honey transfer.
Definitely for serious commercial beekeepers who need reliability and automation.
HH824 40-Frame Honey Extractor with Tables & Pump
This impressive horizontal radial extractor is a game-changer for large-scale producers, effortlessly processing up to 40 frames in a mere 7-10 minutes per cycle.
Efficient, it features durable stainless steel construction, an automatic pump for smooth honey transfer, and often includes convenient integrated tables.
HH825 80-Frame Horizontal Radial Honey Extractor
For truly industrial-scale beekeepers, the HH825 is the ultimate machine, capable of extracting honey from an astounding 80 frames in the same rapid 7-10 minute cycle.
This horizontal radial powerhouse boasts robust stainless steel construction and integrated features like an automatic pump, ensuring continuous high-volume output.
How Mann Lake Stacks Up Against Other Top Brands
While Mann Lake stands tall with its comprehensive and high-quality range, it's always good to see how other respected brands compare. What you'll find is that Mann Lake consistently offers a fantastic balance of quality, innovation, and support, making them a leading choice.
- Lyson: Hailing from Poland, Lyson is known for its exceptionally high-quality, durable extractors, often made from robust stainless steel. They offer a fantastic range, from smaller tangential models perfect for the hobbyist to large radial and cassette extractors boasting advanced features like programmable controllers and energy-saving motors.
Many beekeepers rave about Lyson's smooth performance and solid engineering, particularly their mid-to-large capacity electric radial extractors. While they might come with a higher price point, Lyson extractors are considered a premium investment that truly stands the test of time. For a seasoned beekeeper prioritizing ultimate precision and longevity, Lyson is an excellent choice, but Mann Lake often provides comparable features and durability within a broader reach.
- HillCo: Proudly designed and assembled in the USA, HillCo extractors emphasize incredible durability and user-friendly features. They offer both manual and electric radial extractors, from smaller 4-frame units up to impressive 36-frame and 48-frame extractors.
HillCo's "Maxx" line, in particular, features robust stainless steel tanks, strong drive systems, and innovative details like sloped tank bottoms for complete honey drainage. Their Maxx18 is a popular choice, known for its remarkably smooth and quiet performance and an excellent warranty (up to 10 years on stainless steel!).
If you prioritize American-made quality, strong customer service, and a build that will last a long time, HillCo is a fantastic option. Mann Lake, however, often provides a wider variety of capacities and specialized features across their vast product line.
- Vevor: Vevor has rapidly become a popular choice for budget-conscious beekeepers, offering a wide range of manual extractors and electric extractors at very competitive prices. You'll find everything from compact 2-frame manual units to larger 4-frame and 8-frame electric models.
Many Vevor extractors are made from stainless steel and include features like clear lids and adjustable speed controls on their electric models. While they might require a bit more assembly or minor adjustments out of the box compared to a Mann Lake unit, Vevor offers a very accessible price point for new or small-scale beekeepers looking to get started with a good honey extractor without a huge upfront investment. For those seeking proven reliability and extensive support right out of the gate, Mann Lake remains a stronger contender.
When making your final decision, don't just look at the price point. Consider the material quality (stainless steel construction is highly recommended for durability and hygiene, and Mann Lake consistently delivers here), the reputation for excellent customer service (another Mann Lake strong suit!), and available warranties. And hey, always check for free shipping—extractors can be heavy!
Choosing Your Best Honey Extractor
- How many hives do you have?
- 1-5 hives (backyard beekeeper, hobbyist beekeepers): A 2-frame plastic or a 3-frame stainless steel manual extractor (like the Mann Lake HH130 or the 3-Frame) might be all you need. A smaller electric option (e.g., Mann Lake HH200, or a comparable Vevor unit) could also be a fantastic option for ease of use.
- 5-15 hives (growing hobbyist, small-scale beekeepers): A 6-frame manual radial (like Mann Lake HH162, HH190) or a 4-frame electric/hybrid (like Mann Lake Z177, or a Vevor 4/8 frame electric) would be a good choice. An 18/9 frame manual radial (Mann Lake HH170) or a comparable Lyson manual extractor could also work if you don't mind the physical effort for the larger capacity.
- 15+ hives (larger beekeeping operations, seasoned beekeeper, commercial beekeepers): Electric models with larger capacity (like the Mann Lake Motorized Radial 18/9 Frame, HH280, 24-frame, 48-frame, HillCo Maxx series, or Lyson's larger radial/cassette extractors) are pretty much essential for efficient processing and maximizing honey yield.
- How much honey do you anticipate extracting? A 2-frame extractor might feel tiny if you're pulling a lot of frames. Conversely, a 20-frame extractor would be overkill for just a few frames of honey.
- What type of frames do you primarily use (shallow frames, medium frames, deep frames)? Make sure the extractor can comfortably fit the dimensions of your honeycomb frames. Radial extractors are generally more efficient for shallow and medium frames, while tangential might be necessary for deep frames in smaller units.
- What's your budget? Manual models are typically more affordable, while electric models, especially those with larger capacity or cool features like an auger, are a bigger investment. Think of this piece of equipment as a long-term investment in your beekeeping future.
- How important is physical effort to you? If you have any physical limitations or just prefer convenience, an electric motor is a game-changer.
- Do you have access to electricity where you'll be extracting honey?
Have any questions or would like to place an order? We'd love to help! Chat with our friendly customer service team by calling 1-844-945-3625, chatting in on our website or email us at customersupport@wildoaktrail.com. We look forward to hearing from you!
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of honey extractor is best?
For small hives (1-5), a manual extractor works. For larger operations (5+), an electric extractor is most efficient.
What is the best method of honey extraction?
Centrifugal extraction with an extractor is ideal. It efficiently removes honey while keeping the honeycomb intact for future use.
Which is better, radial or tangential honey extractor?
Radial extractors are typically better for efficiency, as they extract honey from both sides of the frame simultaneously. Tangential extractors require flipping frames.
Which is better manual or automatic honey extractor?
An automatic (electric) honey extractor is better for speed and less physical effort, great for larger volumes. A manual honey extractor is more affordable and portable for smaller harvests.
How big of a honey extractor do I need?
For 1-5 hives, a 2-4 frame extractor is suitable. For 5-15 hives, consider a 6-9 frame. Larger operations need 18+ frame electric models.
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.