Your Cart is Empty
Metal Frame vs. Post-Frame Barndominium Kits: Which is Best for DIY?
How Do Barndominium Kits Compare to Traditional Homes in Value?
You have decided to build a barn-style structure which is an exciting step, but now you face the big debate of Metal vs. Wood Barndominium. While both materials have strong advocates, the differences are massive if you are planning a Do-It-Yourself project.
Choosing the right framing impacts your budget, your timeline, and your sanity during the build. This guide breaks down the differences and highlights why wood post-frame construction—specifically Barndominium Kits like those from Best Barns—might be the smarter path for the average DIYer.
Key Takeaways
- DIY Friendliness: Wood post-frame kits are generally easier for homeowners to assemble using standard tools compared to metal kits.
- Cost Efficiency: Wood kits often have lower upfront material costs and easier finishing options for insulation and drywall.
- Best Barns Homestead: A versatile series offering sizes from storage-only to two-story habitable shells with gambrel roofs.
- Best Barns Colossal: The premium option featuring dormers, elite packages, and massive space for true barndominium living.
- Customization: Both series allow for custom door placement, window additions, and optional commercial-grade flooring upgrades.
Table of Contents
- Which Frame Material is More Practical for DIY: Metal or Wood?
- The Challenges of Metal Frames for Beginners
- The Advantages of Wood Post-Frame Kits
- Why Wood Wins for DIY
- Why Should You Consider the Best Barns Handcrafted Homestead Series?
- Breakdown of Homestead Series Barndominiums
- Is the Best Barns Crafted Colossal Series Right for Your Legacy Build?
- Breakdown of Crafted Colossal Barndominiums
- How Can You Customize Your Barndominium Kit?
- Which Kit Should You Choose?
- Frequently Asked Questions
Which Frame Material is More Practical for DIY: Metal or Wood?
When you look at glossy brochures, metal and wood buildings look similar, but they require very different skill sets under the siding.
The Challenges of Metal Frames for Beginners
Steel is tough because it resists rot, termites, and fire, making it the standard for commercial warehouses. However, metal kits can be tricky for a first-time builder since you often need specialized tools to cut steel on-site.
Unlike wood where you can make easy adjustments, if a metal beam arrives slightly bent or you want to move a window, you are generally locked into the factory design unless you possess welding skills or heavy-duty cutting gear.
The Advantages of Wood Post-Frame Kits
Wood is the traditional choice for a reason as it is incredibly forgiving. If you are building with the Best Barns kits, you are working with premium TimberPrestige™ Eurowood which is strong but easy to modify. You can cut and fasten it with tools you likely already own, like a circular saw and a hammer.
Why Wood Wins for DIY
If you want a structure you can build, finish, and modify yourself, wood post-frame kits usually offer the path of least resistance.
- Easier Insulation: Wood framing creates natural cavities for fiberglass or spray foam insulation.
- Standard Finishing: Hanging drywall or paneling on wood studs is straightforward whereas attaching interior walls to metal requires special screws and furring strips.
- On-Site Adjustments: You can make minor adjustments to the frame without calling an engineer.
Why Should You Consider the Best Barns Handcrafted Homestead Series?
If you lean toward wood construction, the Best Barns Handcrafted Homestead Series is a top contender. These kits use a SecureTruss™ system which makes them incredibly stable while the classic gambrel roof gives you that traditional barn look with modern durability.
Why the Homestead Series Suits DIYers
The Homestead Series uses LP® SmartSide® siding because this material resists fungal decay and termites. It comes primed so you can paint it to match your house immediately, and the modular layout allows you to decide where the windows and doors go for total control over the final look.
Breakdown of Homestead Series Barndominiums
Standard Model – No Loft
This is the entry-level option perfect for those who need maximum headroom for tall equipment.
- Sizes: 12′×16′ or 12′×20′
- Best Feature: 10′10″ center height allows for vertical storage.
- Setup: Barn doors (6′ wide) are centered on the gable side.
Standard Model – With Loft
You get the same footprint but with more utility since this model adds a split-loft area. It is great for keeping seasonal decorations or lumber off the main floor.
- Loft Height: 4′ of headroom in the loft area.
- Access: Includes functional loft doors.
Homestead XL
This is where you step into "Barndominium" territory as the XL is a full two-story structure with a staircase rather than a ladder.
- Wall Height: 8′1″ side walls.
- Versatility: The second floor has 7′1″ of headroom which makes it usable for a workshop or office.
- Note: No doors are included so you can buy unique vintage doors or modern sliders to fit your style.
XL + Transom Door Model
This uses the XL frame but modifies the entrance to be built for big toys.
- Door Opening: 8′ wide × 7′ high transom doors are included.
- Use Case: Ideal for parking ATVs, tractors, or large mowers.
Is the Best Barns Crafted Colossal Series Right for Your Legacy Build?
Sometimes you need more than a shed because you are planning a legacy building. The Crafted Colossal Series is designed for huge storage needs or serious living space conversions. These are massive two-story structures that serve as a blank canvas for your dream build.
Distinctive Features of the Colossal Series
- Elite Package: This series isn't bare bones since it includes dormers and windows to boost curb appeal.
- Staircase Included: You get safe, easy access to the second floor.
- Pre-Cut Precision: Despite the size, the components are pre-cut for assembly.
Breakdown of Crafted Colossal Barndominiums
Man Door + Dormer Kit
This model feels like a cottage or a studio because the inclusion of a 9-Lite man door (a door with glass panes) makes it welcoming.
- Light: Includes two dormer windows and two lower wall windows.
- Access: 36″ wide main entry door.
- Space: 16′×28′ and 16′×32′ sizes available.
Transom Doors + Dormer Kit
This combines the beauty of the dormers with the utility of wide doors.
- Access: Double transom doors (8′×7′ opening) allow vehicle entry.
- Windows: Insulated dormer and lower wall windows are included.
- Use Case: The perfect blend of a garage and a second-story apartment or office.
How Can You Customize Your Barndominium Kit?
One advantage of these wood kits is the ability to upgrade specific components without custom fabrication.
1. The Foundation (FortressFloor™) Never build on a weak base. The optional FortressFloor™ system uses pressure-treated 2×4 joists and ¾″ plywood.
- Garages: 12″ on-center spacing for heavy loads.
- Sheds: 16″ on-center spacing for standard use.
2. Roofing Packages You can source your own shingles, or grab a roof package that includes 25-year 3-tab shingles, ridge vents, and the necessary nails.
3. Doors and Windows
- 6-Panel Steel Door: Solid and secure.
- 9-Lite Steel Door: Adds natural light.
- Windows: Options range from simple fixed octagons to single-hung windows with paintable shutters.
Which Kit Should You Choose?
For the vast majority of homeowners, the Best Barns wood post-frame kit is the clear winner. While metal buildings have a place in industrial settings, wood is simply superior for residential DIY projects.
When you factor in the ease of assembly with standard tools, the straightforward process of adding insulation and drywall, and the lower cost of finishing the interior, a wood kit saves you significant frustration and money. If you want a building that feels like a home and can be built with your own hands, skip the metal shell and choose a Best Barns Barndominium.
Have any questions or would like to place an order? We'd love to help! Chat with our friendly customer service team by calling 1-844-945-3625, chatting in on our website or email us at customersupport@wildoaktrail.com. We look forward to hearing from you!
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a wood or metal barndominium cheaper to build?
Wood kits are generally cheaper for DIYers because metal prices fluctuate and finishing the interior of a metal frame often requires more expensive, specialized materials and labor.
Can I live in a Best Barns kit?
Yes, but you must finish the interior. The kits provide the shell (flooring, walls, roof) so you will need to add insulation, electrical, plumbing, and drywall to meet local habitation codes.
Do these kits come with a floor?
The standard kits do not include a floor as many people build on concrete slabs, but you can add the FortressFloor™ upgrade if you prefer a raised wood floor foundation.
How hard is it to assemble these kits?
It requires basic carpentry skills. The wood is pre-cut and hardware is included so two people can assemble the frame over a weekend, though larger models take longer. No welding is required.
Do I need a permit for these structures?
Yes, most likely. Always check with your local zoning office because you will need to know your setback requirements and maximum height restrictions before ordering a large kit.
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.