Your Cart is Empty
Dickinson Marine vs Magma: Which Marine Grill is Best for Your Boat?
A day on the boat isn’t complete without a mouth-watering BBQ. But grilling on the water comes with high winds, limited space, and the constant motion of the boat, meaning that not just any grill will do.
Unlike your typical backyard BBQ grill setup, marine grills are designed to withstand harsh marine environments, ensuring durability and consistent performance. There are two leading contenders in marine grills: Dickinson Marine and Magma.
Key Takeaways
Dickinson Marine Grill
Dickinson Marine's product line is designed to withstand harsh marine environments while delivering top-notch performance, featuring reliable heaters, compact stoves, marine ovens, and high-quality grills like the Sea-B-Que.
Features of the Dickinson Sea-B-Que Grill
The Sea-B-Que Grill by Dickinson Marine uses propane, offers a generous cooking surface, has a rectangular design for even heat distribution, and comes with versatile mounting options and precise temperature control.
Magma Newport Classic Grill
Magma is known for high-quality marine grills and outdoor cooking equipment, offering kettle grills, rectangular grills, marine accessories, and efficient fuel usage options.
Features of Magma Newport Classic Grill
The Newport Classic Grill by Magma offers 162 square inches of grilling space, operates on propane bottles or tanks, includes a warming rack, ensures even heat distribution, and features reliable flame control.
Dickinson Marine Grill
Dickinson Marine has been a trusted name in the marine industry for decades. From heaters and stoves to ovens and grills, Dickinson Marine’s product line is designed to withstand the harsh marine environment while providing top-notch performance, such as:
Heater
Reliable heating solutions for boats.
Stove
Compact and high-performance stoves for cooking on the go.
Oven
Marine ovens designed for cooking and roasting at sea.
Grill
High-quality marine grills, including the popular Sea-B-Que Grill.
Features of the Dickinson Sea-B-Que Grill
The Sea-B-Que Grill by Dickinson Marine has earned rave reviews from boaters due to the following features:
-
Fuel Type: The grill uses propane bottles, making it convenient for marine use. Propane provides a reliable fuel source that ensures consistent heat, even in heightened winds or on a windy day.
-
Cooking Surface Area: With a generous cooking surface, the grill can handle a party-size meal. Grilling steaks, burgers, or veggies becomes easy with ample space to cook for your crew.
-
Rectangular Grill Design: Rectangular grills maximize the cooking surface and allow for even heat distribution, reducing hot spots. The hinged lid and warming rack provide versatility, letting you cook and keep food warm simultaneously.
-
Mounting Options: The grill comes with mounting hardware, including a rod holder, stern rail mounts, and legs for picnic table setup.
-
Temperature Control: The built-in regulator and heat-resistant handles allow for precise temperature control, ensuring your food is cooked to perfection.
-
Grease Management: The grill features a grease tray that makes it easy to manage drips and keep the cooking area clean.
Advantages
Durable Stainless Steel Construction
The Dickinson Sea-B-Que is built to withstand the harsh marine environment, ensuring longevity and reliability. Unlike some other grills that may rust or degrade over time, the brushed stainless steel of the Dickinson Grill remains spotless, even after numerous uses.
Even Heat Distribution
Grilling on a boat can be challenging, especially with the wind and fluctuating temperatures. The Dickinson Marine excels in providing even heat distribution, ensuring that your meals cook evenly without any hot spots.
Easy to Clean and Maintain
Cleaning and maintaining a marine grill can be a hassle, but the Dickinson Sea-B-Que makes it simple. The grill features a removable grease tray and grill racks, which can be easily taken out and cleaned. Additionally, the stainless steel surface is easy to wipe down, preventing the buildup of grease and grime.
Versatile Mounting Options
The Dickinson Marine offers versatile mounting options, making it suitable for various setups. Whether you prefer to mount it on a rod holder, stern rail, or picnic table, the Sea-B-Que can be securely attached using the included mounting hardware.
Drawbacks
Slightly Heavier Than Competitors
The Dickinson Sea-B-Que is slightly heavier than some of its competitors, such as the Magma Kettle grill and the Kuuma Stow. While the extra weight contributes to sturdiness, it may be a concern for those looking for a lighter, more portable option.
Higher Price Point
The Dickinson Grill comes with a higher price point compared to some other models on the market. While the quality and durability justify the investment, budget-conscious buyers might find the initial cost to be a bit steep. However, considering the long-term benefits and the reduced need for frequent replacements, many users find the cost to be worth it in the long run.
Magma Newport Classic Grill
Magma has established itself as a premier company in the world of marine grills and outdoor cooking equipment. Below is a quick rundown of what Magma offers:
Kettle Grills
Iconic for their round shape and even heat distribution.
Rectangular Grills
Known for more cooking surfaces and accommodating larger meals.
Marine Accessories
Including grill mounts, covers, and cooking utensils.
Propane Bottles and Regulators
Ensuring safe and efficient fuel usage.
Features of Magma Newport Classic Grill
Some standout features and specifications that make Magma a great grill:
-
Surface: A generous 162 square inches of grilling space, ample for making multiple burgers, steaks, or seafood at once.
-
Fuel Type: Operates on a standard 1-pound propane bottle but can be adapted to larger propane tanks for extended use.
-
Warming Rack: An integrated warming rack increases cooking capacity, which is perfect for keeping meals warm.
-
Heat Distribution: Features a radiant plate and convection heating system to ensure even heat distribution across the cooking surface, minimizing hot spots.
-
Flame Control: Equipped with a reliable, adjustable regulator and control valve for precise heat control, whether you’re searing steaks or slow-cooking ribs.
Advantages
Exceptional Build Quality
The Newport Classic Grill boasts brushed stainless steel construction, making it not only sleek and modern but also resistant to rust and corrosion.
Convenient Mounting Options
The grill comes with various mounting hardware options, including a rod holder and a stern rail mount. These mounts allow for secure attachment to your boat, providing stability even in high winds. The versatility in mounting options makes it easy to set up and use in different boating conditions.
Ease of Use and Storage
The Newport Classic Grill features a lid that remains attached to the grill, preventing any issues with the lid from falling off or getting lost. The lid also locks in place, which is great for safety during grilling and storage.
Versatile Fuel Options
This marine grill supports both propane tanks and bottles, providing flexibility depending on your needs.
Drawbacks
Propane Regulator Complications
Some users have reported issues with the propane regulator, noting that it can be finicky and require adjustments to maintain a steady flame.
Lack of Charcoal Option
For those who prefer the flavor that comes with charcoal grilling, the Newport Classic Grill might not be the best choice as it does not offer a charcoal version.
Comparison Chart
Conclusion
Choosing the right marine grill comes down to your specific needs and preferences. The Dickinson is the go-to for larger boats that need a larger grilling surface, more capacity, and excellent heat management. On the other hand, the design, fold-away legs, and ceramic-coated stainless steel construction of Mgma make it a practical option for most boating situations.
Have any questions or would like to place an order? We'd love to help! Chat with our friendly customer service team by calling 1-844-945-3625, chatting in on our website or email us at customersupport@wildoaktrail.com. We look forward to hearing from you!
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.