Your Cart is Empty
Wood Garage Kits vs. Metal Garage Kits: Durability and Aesthetics Compared
Choosing the right material is the first big hurdle when planning your new garage build. You are likely weighing the classic appeal of wood garage kits against the industrial utility of metal garage kits. While both will protect your vehicles from the elements, the similarities stop there. These two options offer completely different assembly experiences, maintenance schedules, and long-term value.
We are going to break down the specific pros and cons of each to help you decide which structure belongs on your property.
Key Takeaways
- Aesthetic Impact: Wood garage kits offer a traditional look that blends with residential homes, while metal kits often have an industrial or agricultural appearance.
- Durability Factors: Metal is immune to rot and termites but prone to rust and dents. Wood is robust and rigid but requires painting to prevent water damage.
- Maintenance Needs: Metal kits are generally "set and forget," whereas wood kits need repainting every 5–10 years to stay protected.
- Assembly Experience: Metal kits bolt together quickly with lightweight panels. Wood kits involve traditional carpentry with studs and siding, allowing for easier on-site adjustments.
- Customization: It is much easier to finish the interior of a wood garage with insulation and shelving because you are working with standard studs.
The Aesthetic Factor: Curb Appeal
This is usually the deciding factor for homeowners who want their new garage to look like an asset rather than a warehouse.
Wood Garage Kits
A wood kit, such as the Best Barns Tailored Titan, is designed to look like a permanent extension of your home. It features eaves, trim, and siding that mimics residential construction. Since you paint it yourself, you can match your house’s color scheme perfectly.
If you live in a suburban neighborhood with an HOA, a wood kit is often the safer choice because it blends in seamlessly.
Metal Garage Kits
Metal kits tend to look utilitarian. They often feature vertical or horizontal ribbed panels and a rounded or low-pitch roof.
While modern metal kits come in various factory colors, they still carry the "workshop" or "shed" vibe. If you have a large lot or a farm where function matters more than form, this might not be an issue.
Durability Comparison
Both materials are strong, but they handle the elements differently.
Wood Durability
Wood is heavy and rigid, handling wind and snow loads exceptionally well thanks to internal truss systems. However, wood’s enemy is moisture.
If you fail to paint and caulk it properly, it will eventually rot. If you let the bottom edge touch the dirt, termites become a risk. But with proper maintenance, a wood garage can easily last 30 to 50 years.
Metal Durability
Steel is immune to rot and termites, making metal garage kits incredibly durable in damp, swampy environments. However, metal has its own weaknesses: rust and impact damage.
If the protective coating gets scratched, rust can spread quickly. Additionally, a heavy hail storm or a stray baseball can dent metal siding permanently, whereas wood siding would likely absorb the impact without showing damage.
The Assembly Experience
The construction process varies significantly between the two.
Assembling Wood
Building a Best Barns kit is like framing a house on a smaller scale. You hammer 2x4s, nail up sheets of siding, and install shingles.
It is labor-intensive and requires cutting wood, but it is also very forgiving. If you nail a stud in the wrong place, you can simply pull it out and fix it.
Assembling Metal
Metal kits typically use a "bolt-together" system. You connect pre-drilled frames and screw on sheet metal panels. It goes up much faster—often in a single weekend—but it can be frustrating.
If the factory holes do not line up perfectly, you cannot force the metal like you can wood. You also have to be careful with sharp metal edges, making heavy gloves a necessity.
Customization and Interior Use
If you plan to use the garage as a workshop, the interior structure matters.
Wood
Since a wood kit has studs spaced 16 or 24 inches apart, finishing the inside is straightforward. You can run electrical wiring through the studs, add insulation batts, and hang drywall.
You can screw hooks anywhere to hang bikes or tools. It feels like a real room.
Metal
Metal kits usually have thin walls and wide frame spacing (sometimes 4 to 5 feet). It is difficult to hang shelves or drywall because there is often nothing solid to screw into.
To insulate it, you typically have to use spray foam, which can be messy and expensive. If you want a finished, comfortable interior, wood is the clear winner.
Which One is Right for You?
Choose a Wood Garage Kit if:
- You want a building that increases your property value and matches your home.
- You plan to add electricity, insulation, and drywall for a workshop.
- You are comfortable with painting and basic carpentry tools.
Choose a Metal Garage Kit if:
- You need the cheapest possible storage solution.
- You want to build it fast and prefer not to paint.
- You live in a very wet area where wood rot is a constant battle.
Have any questions or would like to place an order? We'd love to help! Chat with our friendly customer service team by calling 1-844-945-3625, chatting in on our website or email us at customersupport@wildoaktrail.com. We look forward to hearing from you!
Frequently Asked Questions
Are metal garage kits cheaper than wood kits?
Generally, yes. A basic metal kit is often 20-30% cheaper upfront than a wood kit because it includes the roof and siding, whereas wood kits require buying shingles and paint separately.
Which one is better for snow loads?
Both are capable, but wood kits with "trussed" roofs (like Best Barns) are specifically engineered for high snow loads. Some cheaper metal kits can buckle under heavy snow if not upgraded to a thicker gauge steel.
Can I paint a metal garage?
Yes, but it requires specific preparation. You need special metal primer and paint to ensure it bonds. Wood siding is designed to be painted, making it much easier to change the color later.
Do metal garages sweat?
Yes. Condensation is a common issue in metal buildings. If you do not install a vapor barrier or insulation, water can drip from the ceiling on cold mornings. Wood breathes better and rarely has this issue.
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.