Your Cart is Empty
ECOJOHN VS Cinderella
When choosing the best incinerating toilet for your off-grid lifestyle, finding the right brand will help you save a lot of time, money, and effort in the bathroom. We’ll compare two of the best incinerating toilet makers, pitting the ECOJOHN Tiny John Incinerating Toilet models with the Cinderella line. Find out the key differences, similarities, and what makes each brand unique, along with why ECOJOHN is usually the smarter choice.
At a Glance
ECOJOHN and Cinderella incinerating toilets both offer waterless, hygienic waste disposal for off-grid living, but ECOJOHN stands out as the more practical choice for many. With its flexible power options, simple operation, durable construction, and affordable price, ECOJOHN caters to the needs of off-grid dwellers seeking a reliable and hassle-free solution. While Cinderella models boast advanced features and sleek designs, they often come with a higher price tag and require more maintenance. Ultimately, ECOJOHN provides exceptional value and performance for those prioritizing practicality and cost-effectiveness in their off-grid bathroom setup.
Differences Between an Incinerator Toilet and a Composting Toilet
Before we find out what the better brand is, it’s essential to understand the fundamental differences between an incinerating toilet and a composting toilet.
Incinerating Toilet
These toilets burn poop and urine into ash, reducing waste to a small bag-sized amount that’s easy to dispose of. They’re waterless, making them ideal for off-grid applications where water conservation is essential. Incinerating toilets, like those from ECOJOHN and Cinderella, offer a hygienic solution with minimal maintenance, requiring only a power source, such as electricity or propane, to operate.
Composting Toilet
A composting toilet breaks down waste through a natural process, turning it into compost over time. They usually require a fresh water tank for liquid flushes and regular maintenance to manage the compost. While they are effective in reducing waste and can be used to create compost for gardens, they often require more space and can emit odors if not properly maintained.
Similarities Between ECOJOHN and Cinderella Incinerating Toilets
Both ECOJOHN and Cinderella incinerating toilets share several important features:
- Waterless: Both brands offer a waterless way for you to do your business, making them perfect for off-grid living, van conversions, remote locations, or as emergency toilets during droughts.
- Easy Cleaning and Emptying: The incineration process in both ECOJOHN and Cinderella toilets results in sterile ash, which is easy to handle and eliminates odors.
- Compact Design: These toilets are designed to fit into small spaces, whether you’re outfitting a cabin, RV, or tiny home.
- Efficient Waste Reduction: By burning waste into a small amount of ash, these toilets help reduce waste and the need for frequent waste disposal and the use of black tanks.
Key Differences
While ECOJOHN and Cinderella share many similarities, there are key differences that could influence your decision
Incineration Method
- The ECOJOHN TinyJohn and TinyJohn XL models offer both propane and electric options, giving users flexibility in their energy choices.
- The Cinderella Comfort and Cinderella Freedom models are electric-only, making them more suited for locations where a stable electricity supply is available. The Cinderella Travel model, however, operates on propane, making it more comparable to ECOJOHN’s offerings for remote, off-grid applications.
Control and Usability
- ECOJOHN models are known for their straightforward operation and user-friendly control panels, which are particularly helpful in off-grid settings. Compared to cassette toilets, ECOJOHN models offer a more convenient waste management solution without the need for frequent waste container removal.
- Cinderella toilets are also user-friendly, with some models including more advanced features like automatic flushing and self-cleaning systems in the Cinderella Comfort and Cinderella Freedom models. The tradeoff is they require more maintenance and have higher power needs.
Design and Installation
- The TinyJohn and its XL variant are designed for durability and larger waste capacity, making them ideal for bigger families or commercial use. They are robust and easy to install, with clear instructions and minimal ongoing maintenance. They also boast a minimalist look, helping them blend with whatever your bathroom's style is.
- Cinderella toilets, particularly the Cinderella Comfort, boast a sleek, modern design with a focus on indoor aesthetics, making them more appealing for residential use. For mobile use, such as in RVs or boats, the Cinderella Travel is a good choice.
Cost and Availability
- ECOJOHN toilets, including the TinyJohn and TinyJohn XL, are competitively priced and readily available with region-specific models.
- Cinderella models tend to be on the higher end of the price spectrum, reflecting their advanced features and Scandinavian engineering.
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
| Model | ECOJOHN TinyJohn | ECOJOHN TinyJohn XL | Cinderella Comfort | Cinderella Freedom | Cinderella Travel |
| Power Source | Propane/Electric | Propane/Electric | Electric | Electric | Propane |
| Water Usage | Waterless | Waterless | Waterless | Waterless | Waterless |
| Weight | 65 lbs (29.5 kg) | 85 lbs (38.5 kg) | 75 lbs (34 kg) | 75 lbs (34 kg) | 44 lbs (20 kg) |
| Dimensions (H x W x D) | 22" x 14" x 20.5" | 25" x 17" x 23" | 24" x 15" x 23" | 24" x 15" x 23" | 21" x 15" x 23" |
| Energy Consumption | Urine Cycle: 0.09 lbs/cycle Waste Cycle: 0.19 lbs/cycle or Urine Cycle: 1200 Watt/hr Waste Cycle: 2000 Watt/hr |
Urine Cycle: 0.09 lbs/cycle Waste Cycle: 0.19 lbs/cycle or Urine Cycle: 1200 Watt/hr Waste Cycle: 2900 Watt/hr |
1-2 kWh/cycle | 0.35 to 0.4 lbs/cycle or 1.3 Amp/cycle |
0.3 to 0.4 lbs/cycle or 1.3 Amp/cycle |
| Maintenance | Low maintenance | Low maintenance | Requires regular servicing | Requires regular servicing | Low maintenance, suited for mobile use |
| Capacity | 30 flushes/day | 60 flushes/day | 4 visits per hour | 4 visits per hour | Up to 6 people |
| Control Panel | Simple and user-friendly | Simple and user-friendly | Advanced, with automatic features | Advanced, with automatic features | Basic, designed for simplicity |
What Others Say
If you're still finding it difficult to choose between these two, maybe some of our users' experiences can help.
ECOJOHN TinyJohn
One couple decided to make their off-grid cabin in Alaska a permanent residence and sought to upgrade from their composting toilet to a more efficient, low-maintenance option. After evaluating their choices, they opted for the TinyJohn over the Cinderella due to its lower power consumption and more affordable price. Despite some initial concerns regarding shipping and installation, which were addressed by ECOJOHN's customer service, the TinyJohn has exceeded their expectations. True to its expectations, the toilet is easy to use, maintain, and clean, with a modern design that complements their cabin.
Cinderella
Users of the Cinderella Comfort often highlight its sleek design and modern features, though it usually has a persistent, distinct odor—especially with urine. It's easy to use, with the automatic features and self-cleaning systems often being praised. Many customers find it ideal for indoor use, where aesthetics and advanced technology are priorities. However, some users have mentioned the higher initial cost compared to pretty much any other toilet, along with its very high electricity usage.
Why Choose ECOJOHN?
Choosing an ECOJOHN incinerating toilet, particularly the Tiny John or TinyJohn XL, offers several distinct advantages:
- Energy Flexibility: With options for both propane and electric power, ECOJOHN toilets provide versatility for different off-grid setups.
- Ease of Use and Maintenance: ECOJOHN’s straightforward design and minimal maintenance needs make it a hassle-free option, especially for those new to off-grid living.
- Durability: Built to last, especially in demanding environments, the TinyJohn XL is a reliable choice for long-term use.
- Affordability: ECOJOHN offers a cost-effective solution compared to Cinderella, making it a practical choice for those looking to invest in a high-quality incinerator toilet without breaking the bank.
Conclusion
Both ECOJOHN and Cinderella incinerator toilets offer reliable and efficient waste management solutions, but they cater to slightly different needs. If you require a flexible, easy-to-maintain, and durable incinerator toilet for off-grid living or van conversion, ECOJOHN might be your best bet. On the other hand, if you prefer a more feature-rich, electric-only option with a modern design fit for a residential or mobile home, Cinderella toilets could be the ideal choice.
By choosing ECOJOHN, you’re opting for a reliable, cost-effective, and versatile solution that aligns perfectly with the demands of modern off-grid living, all without paying triple the amount.
Have any questions or would like to place an order? We'd love to help! Chat with our friendly customer service team by calling 1-844-945-3625, chatting in on our website or email us at customersupport@wildoaktrail.com. We look forward to hearing from you!
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.